The more I know about food, the less I know.

I mean, who knew in order to make homemade vanilla ice cream, you had to cook the custard twenty-four hours in advance?

Sigh.

Please indulge me while I offer up a slice of backstory.

I was attempting to make banana ice cream for Elvis and his grandson’s Erik’s twenty-fifth birthday, and since I didn’t have the original salt and crank method, I at least knew I needed to start with a vanilla ice cream base. Note: I waited to make said ice cream on the day we invited Erik for burgers and ice cream, (yes, seriously) after I listened to Elvis the previous day warn me not to give him any excuses why I didn’t make said ice cream, please and thank you.

I remember reading a post on David’s blog, (you know David Lebovitz, The Sweet Life in Paris David?) about how everyone should have a good recipe for vanilla ice cream. Side bar: Where was I when those recipes were handed out?

Anyway, that’s when I discovered the twenty-four hour ahead step in the recipe. So of course I scoured the Internet for other recipes and sure enough, that twenty-four hour ahead step is not really a step but the RULE for making custard for vanilla ice cream.

So off I went to the market determined to make do, which is what life is about anyway, isn’t it?

I was pleasantly surprised to find a caramelized banana tart filling on the shelf. Refer to my first sentence please.

One 23-ounce jar of banana fruit tart and $12.00 later, I had a plan.

How to Make the Best Banana Ice Cream

Buy a quart of vanilla bean ice cream, swirl in ¼ cup banana tart filling, add one sliced, very ripe banana, and about a dozen crushed vanilla wafers. Then plop the runny concoction back into vanilla ice cream carton and freeze to create the best banana ice cream.

Elvis’s expression? Priceless.

Share This Banana Ice Cream Recipe, Choose Your Platform!